Page 1 of 1

Air cleaner price shock

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 2:42 pm
by TOONGA
So Im back from an excursion to town with my daughter in tow, who by the way loves going shopping for tools with daddy.

I priced a ryco air cleaner for my vortex part number a345 which came in at $35.99 hmmmm me thinks... I wonder if they have a part listing for the K&N air cleaner. 332010 I think was the part number, of course being country none in stock. the nice lady rang Perth $172.95 and wait for it $13.95 freight.

My daughter said NO in a very stern voice... the girl behind the counter nearly peed herself laughing.

I thanked her and she thanked me and Meme for making her day.

I already have a project in play with some filter mat that cost 17 dollars for nearly half a square metre. it is specifically designed for air filters for cars.

TOONGA

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 3:19 pm
by NachaLuva
hahaha good one! Image

Thats one very clever, wise girl you have Toonga :mrgreen:

Let us know how you go with the filter project. I would love to replace mine...its such a pain to access!

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 3:31 pm
by RSR 555
Yeah.. hard to work out how they come up with those prices?? I think even the STi one in the 22B is cheaper than that and it's a foam/cloth type.

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 4:09 pm
by TOONGA
I believe they use a chocolate wheel

I have found a used K&N air filter in the US for 25 dollars just waiting to see if he will ship to Australia

TOONGA

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 5:46 pm
by coupe
Glad the Jetcar is going great Jules. Geeze i paid $20 for one the last time i got a new one. i picked up a K& N pod filter of the verge last year during a council waste collection its going into the auto vortex.
Cheers Pete

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 6:15 pm
by TOONGA
I have just found this option as well the K&N 33 - 2232

http://www.knfilters.com/search/applica ... od=33-2232

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/33-2232-K-N- ... 43a58f0e35

under 60 dollars delivered from the UK

TOONGA

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 10:57 pm
by NachaLuva
Arent you worried bout the oil-soaked filter gunking things up? I had a Finer Filter on a falcon & crikey it left a mess! :(

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 11:02 pm
by steptoe
the K&N ain't really an oil bath foam jobby is it? Had them..... Pheonix filters do good priced paper elements

Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 11:44 pm
by El_Freddo
I've been told that one of the bommerdore's air filters are the same as the EJ/L series MPFI for about $10 less :D I think it was a VN...

Cheers

Bennie

Air filters

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 12:38 am
by pitrack_1
Hmmm, you all think that's bad? At least they are engine air filters.

Take the Forester Diesel. It's &*@% $89 for a filter and it's not even for the engine- it's the #^$*&% aircon @*^^&$ #@&$! pollen filter that no-one %(A^&@! wants anyway! ***

And expected every *#^$% 12 months! Grrr! And they charged me without warning...

If anyone's figured out what material to get (HEPA filter of some sort?) and how to exchange it into the current frame/housing could they please let me know? Or an aftermarket one?

*** Sorry. It seems I confused the ((@&#^ hashes with the alphabet keys on my keyboard. :mrgreen:

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 5:18 am
by Gannon
wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA

I just wash the pollen filter of my Outback.

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 8:47 am
by TOONGA
as long as the K&N filter isn't over oiled (or oiled for that matter) they are not a problem

HEPA filters are great if they are made of materials that withstand repeated washing otherwise they degrade and let larger particles through

still looking into my project as well :)

TOONGA

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 10:49 am
by NachaLuva
pitrack_1 wrote:Hmmm, you all think that's bad? At least they are engine air filters.

Take the Forester Diesel. It's &*@% $89 for a filter and it's not even for the engine- it's the #^$*&% aircon @*^^&$ #@&$! pollen filter that no-one %(A^&@! wants anyway! ***

And expected every *#^$% 12 months! Grrr! And they charged me without warning...

If anyone's figured out what material to get (HEPA filter of some sort?) and how to exchange it into the current frame/housing could they please let me know? Or an aftermarket one?

*** Sorry. It seems I confused the ((@&#^ hashes with the alphabet keys on my keyboard. :mrgreen:
hahaha i thought so :rolleyes:

But wouldnt you be glad if you have to follow a cattle truck or rubbish truck? Or a passenger unwittingly pollutes the air (never the driver lol) :p

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 10:51 am
by NachaLuva
TOONGA wrote:as long as the K&N filter isn't over oiled (or oiled for that matter) they are not a problem
According to their website they are oiled :(

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 11:14 am
by Subyroo
pitrack_1 wrote:Hmmm, you all think that's bad? At least they are engine air filters.

Take the Forester Diesel. It's &*@% $89 for a filter and it's not even for the engine- it's the #^$*&% aircon @*^^&$ #@&$! pollen filter that no-one %(A^&@! wants anyway! ***

And expected every *#^$% 12 months! Grrr! And they charged me without warning...

If anyone's figured out what material to get (HEPA filter of some sort?) and how to exchange it into the current frame/housing could they please let me know? Or an aftermarket one?

*** Sorry. It seems I confused the ((@&#^ hashes with the alphabet keys on my keyboard. :mrgreen:
You think that's dear?, then you had better start putting some big dollars aside for the DPF for when it has to be replaced then, I believe it's up around the $3k mark.


:( :( :( :(

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 4:27 pm
by Smokey
El_Freddo wrote:I've been told that one of the bommerdore's air filters are the same as the EJ/L series MPFI for about $10 less :D I think it was a VN...

Cheers

Bennie
I think it's the A360 same as the VL maybe others. Around $15 at SCA.

Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 6:01 pm
by GOD
Smokey wrote:I think it's the A360 same as the VL maybe others. Around $15 at SCA.

A360 is used in most VL-VT Commodores and early EJs. MPFI L Series use A345, which is much less common and more expensive.

An A360 can be made to fit the L airbox with some foam packing.

Dane.

DPF cost and durability

Posted: Sat Nov 05, 2011 11:14 pm
by pitrack_1
Subyroo wrote:You think that's dear?, then you had better start putting some big dollars aside for the DPF for when it has to be replaced then, I believe it's up around the $3k mark.
Hmm, yes, quite right! I've seen that quote somewhere else... had forgotten it was a filter! Cost was also in Euro I think, making it worse.

I've decided either:
a) DPF Prices will drop as aftermarket ones become available- any exhaust place will do a catalytic converter now, the same should be true for DPFs in the future.
b) I'll trade out of the vehicle before I reach that point- I'm lucky enough to have that option. Alternatives are becoming (or are already) available.

Couple of documents point to some reasonable lifetime expectations for light-duty DPFs: min 100,000 miles/160,000kms (tested) and 120,000 miles (~193,000 kms) mandated in USA. Heavy duty vehicles run much further.

http://www.swri.org/9what/events/confer ... 20Zhan.pdf
http://www.nrel.gov/vehiclesandfuels/ap ... /39010.pdf
http://www.aecc.eu/content/pdf/AECC%20P ... 020206.pdf
http://www.aecc.eu/content/pdf/AECC%20- ... 200805.pdf

Note these papers/talks all predate Euro5, one as far back as 2004. Predicted technologies then are now in production. I imagine the Europeans would kick up a big stink if/when their DPF-equipped vehicles age and start requiring new DPFs.